All Debates
leadershipmetricscultureDebate #09

Optimize Metrics vs. Follow Mission

Should you optimize for measurable KPIs, or stay true to a broader mission even when metrics suffer?

15

Experts

HIGH Tension
Optimize MetricsTension: HIGHMission Over Metrics
8
7
53% of experts47% of experts
Side A · 8 Advocates

Optimize Metrics

What gets measured gets managed. Set clear KPIs and optimize relentlessly.

Side B · 7 Advocates

Mission Over Metrics

Metrics can mislead. Sometimes the right thing for users hurts short-term numbers.

Advocates for “Optimize Metrics”

Crystal Widjaja

2022-07-31

How to scrappily hire for, measure, and unlock growth | Crystal Widjaja, Gojek and Kumu

Eppo does all that and more. Delivering results quickly, avoiding annoying prolonged analytics cycles and helping you easily get to the root cause of any issue you discover. Eppo lets you go beyond basic clickthrough metrics and instead uses our north star metrics like activation, retention, subscriptions and payments.
Crystal Widjaja Yes. Please find me at crystalwidjaja.com. You can reach out to me and my email is there. Listeners, please do instrumentation correctly. Please don't track your KPIs. Please track your user journeys and experiences. We'll have much funner things to talk about if you do that.

Asha Sharma

2025-08-28

How 80,000 companies build with AI: Products as organisms and the death of org charts | Asha Sharma

So everybody has that shared sense. What is the north star metric is something that we do. The second thing that we do is that we have kind of loose quarterly OKR. So like, "Okay, if we believe that, what do we need to do next quarter to actually put ourselves on a path to that?" And then from there, teams are operating in squads and they'...
I think why we're seeing the rise of post-training happen is just that the models themselves are so powerful. As of this year, Nathan Lambert did this study that I thought was pretty interesting of all the top leader boards and it showed that once a model hits 30 billion parameters, the CapEx to actually train a model and put billions of t...

Casey Winters

2022-07-21

How to sell your ideas and rise within your company | Casey Winters, Eventbrite

When I was at Airbnb, one of the things that I loved about our experimentation platform was being able to easily slice results by device, by country, and by user stage. Eppo does all that and more, delivering results quickly, avoiding annoying prolonged analytics cycles, and helping you easily get to the root cause of any issue you discover.
I think about it a little bit, depending on the type of job you have and the types of customers you have. The more scale you have tends to be you have less sophisticated customers because you're generally like a consumer thing where the customers are rational. They're not experts. That's generally where you just try things.

Dan Hockenmaier

2022-10-09

Developing a growth model + marketplace growth strategy | Dan Hockenmaier

And similarly with paid marketing, as you generate contribution margin, you can reinvest that and grow and actually if you link those two up explicitly, it makes it really clear why thinking about something like payback period is a much better measure of paid marketing performance than LTV to CAC because the speed at which you get enough money back...
I mean the first time this was very eye-opening to me and probably the first one I built was the one we built at Thumbtack in partnership with our finance team, and it made it so immediately obvious that we were exceptionally sensitive to the repeat rate of new customers. If you think about Thumbtack, we offered a thousand categories.

Hila Qu

2023-04-02

The ultimate guide to adding a PLG motion | Hila Qu (Reforge, GitLab)

Time to value need to be relatively short or you can figure out a way to make it short. And then do you have a lot of potentially end user S&B business? They are interested in the solution. They want to try that out. If you do not have both, if you for example, develop a software for the [inaudible 00:18:42]. Companies like [inaudible 00:18:44].
And then you need to have an experimentation tool because, like I said, you cannot just imagine you build everything and everything works perfectly. So you need either like Optimizely, I know Amplitude has some experimentation components. Eppo is a new and upcoming one. You need some tool to allow you to do experimentation.

Itamar Gilad

2023-09-21

Becoming evidence-guided | Itamar Gilad (Gmail, YouTube, Microsoft)

Where basically the organization is trying to deliver as much value as it can to the market and to capture as much value back, and by creating a feedback loop between these two you are actually able to grow very fast.
So the North Star metric is measuring how much value we're creating for the user, the core value that they're getting. In this case this is some productivity suite, so this is number of documents created per month for example. Because we think that every document created maybe it's a small document, I don't know.

Jason M Lemkin

2026-01-01

We replaced our sales team with 20 AI agents—here’s what happened next | Jason Lemkin (SaaStr)

Jason Lemkin As you can see, I have a lot of opinions on things here that are data-driven and they're live experience. This one, I need another year in the oven, and I'll tell you why. I'll tell you why. What happened in the last 18 months is, in customer success, which is, in the old days, it was related to product.

Jonathan Lowenhar

2024-12-05

How a great founder becomes a great CEO | Jonathan Lowenhar (co-founder of Enjoy The Work)

The second one, and this is going to sound a little silly, but I am not exaggerating, it works. If you are a CEO founder and you have that title on LinkedIn, it's amazing the responses you'll get. So we made this list and we just started to send connection requests to the CEOs or CPOs or CFOs on our target list, and said something as simple as this...
The scaler is saying, okay, now how do I find leverage? How do I have 10X more account execs or how to get other people to sell for me? They're all going to be called VP of sales or chief revenue officer. They're completely different archetypes, and that same person exists in engineering and in product, et cetera.

Advocates for “Mission Over Metrics”

Ada Chen Rekhi

2023-04-21

Feeling stuck? Here's how to know when it's time to leave your job | Ada Chen Rekhi

Yeah, and it's really self-aware of you too. I think too. Cut it off because you start realizing that you're doing this course, and it's not giving you energy or it's not quite the right thing. It's really hard to say no to things.
So a coach might be a really helpful shortcut for them to get there. Related to that, I think it's also really helpful on sensitive topics. So there are a lot of things that we want to be coached on where either it takes a lot of time for us to work through and progress because it's a long-term project, for example, or it's something very sensitive...

Albert Cheng

2025-10-05

Finding hidden growth opportunities in your product | Albert Cheng (Duolingo, Grammarly, Chess.com)

It's flexible so it adapts to the way your team works and helps you build a roadmap that drives alignment, not questions. And because it's built on Jira, you can track ideas from strategy to delivery all in one place, less chasing, more time to think, learn and build the right thing. Get Jira Product Discovery for free at Atlassian.
Yeah, I think first of all, why do freemium subscription in the first place is a common question that I've joined all these companies that are freemium subscription. What do I like about it I guess? Well one, I think it ties really nicely to mission orientation of a lot of these companies.

Alex Komoroske

2024-10-03

Thinking like a gardener, slime mold, the adjacent possible: Product advice from Alex Komoroske

And also, I built a feature into it that uses embeddings to find similar cards. I find similar ideas from the past. And then what I do on Friday afternoons is I sit down and I go through all the notes I added that week and I just click and check the ones that still resonate with me, they still seem interesting in some way.
Someone described to me actually this morning in one of my little dirt clubs I run about they help facilitate about treat everybody like the Buddha. I think is I'm messing this up, but this notion of imagine everyone you talk to is the Buddha, in a Buddhist mindset, and how do you see and find those seeds of greatness and treat everyone with respec...

Ami Vora

2024-06-23

Making an impact through authenticity and curiosity | Ami Vora (CPO at Faire, ex-WhatsApp, FB, IG)

I think I got that same feedback quite a lot, actually, of needing to think bigger and be more visionary, etc. And I still do, frankly, actually, there's moments where I retrench way too far into execution and worry a little less about long-term strategy. So it's definitely my bias still.
Yeah, I mean, I was so lucky. I had such an amazing run at Meta. I got to work with amazing leaders, truly great products. And I came to Faire for the same reason that I've been anywhere, because I believe in the people and I believe in the mission.

Archie Abrams

2024-03-31

How to speak more confidently and persuasively | Matt Abrahams (professor, speaker, author)

And because we focus on that long-term GMV, number of merchants who are successful, orienting every team to think about the total number of people, not the rate, but the total number of people who got to the end of their part of the journey is a very powerful way to incentivize people to do the right thing in terms of getting people set up versus d...
Some examples include their priorities in product roadmap are driven by a 100-year vision that comes from Tobi, the CEO. And the core product teams don't have metrics or KPIs. They're essentially banned. And instead, decisions are made based on taste, and intuition, and building towards this long-term vision.

Benjamin Mann

2024-09-29

How marketplaces win: Liquidity, growth levers, quality, more | Benjamin Lauzier (Lyft, Thumbtack)

I'm going to kind of zoom out a little bit and talk about just why this is so core to you. What was your inception of just like, holy shit, I need to focus on this with everything I do in ai? Obviously it became a central part of Anthropic's mission more than any other company.
And so I think about that as the busy state is the normal state and to try to work at a sustainable pace that it's a marathon, not a sprint, that's one thing that helps. And then just being around like-minded people that also care. It's not a thing that any of us can do alone. And Anthropic has incredible talent density.

Brian Balfour

2025-08-17

Why ChatGPT will be the next big growth channel (and how to capitalize on it) | Brian Balfour

Do you think that has longevity in the sense that... That makes sense in the current environment that we're sitting in right now because people are comparing these outcomes relative to what it costs them today with pure humans.
Yeah, 100%, and that's exactly what I think you see them doing. Look, to be very clear, I have not talked to anybody at HubSpot about this. I have not talked to Dharmesh about this, but Dharmesh I think has also published about this.

Submit Your Take

234 votes cast

Community Results234 total votes
40%
60%
Optimize Metrics (93)Mission Over Metrics (141)

Community Takes

1 comment · Share your perspective

Diana V.Mission Over Metrics5d ago

We optimized for DAU so hard that we added dark patterns. Users hated us. Now we optimize for 'would you recommend this to a friend?'